Novel Audit Checklist
A point of reflection in the Algonkian Novel Writing and Development Program wherein writers honestly and cautiously scorebox or rate their own novel-in-progress according to an array of criteria. To be approached upon completion of the 14th course module. Participation is not strictly mandatory.
75 topics in this forum
-
- 3 replies
- 628 views
Dear Writer, Below are coverage categories and criteria we use to help us rate novel projects. You need to use these criteria and do a self-audit of your novel, and you need to do it and post your coverage in this forum before approaching Author Salon with a call for a review of your novel-in-progress master profile you will create upon completion of the 16th module. Can you be honest with yourself? Even the most deluded narcissist will find it difficult to wade through the criteria below and "high five" themselves with supporting evidence. But then again, that's the whole idea. Pardon our sense of black humor! Please consider though ... How can you possibly appro…
Last reply by ChrisGoldschmidt, -
- 0 replies
- 50 views
(Disclaimer: All the 5s and most of the 4s are humbly stated). Originality, freshness, high concept: 5 The plot and concepts of this novel are original not only in the sense of the relatively rare combination of urban/ethnic with ultra-advanced scifi/technology, but in the sense that there is the featuring of a wide range of cultural characters and origins. The scenic stage of this concept ranges from the environment of an ultra-violent urban American ghetto, the launching site for the protagonist, to multi-linguistic "high-end" societies of eastern and western Europe, the native base for the alpha protagonist, the international terrorists. Besides highl…
Last reply by Cavis Adams, -
- 1 reply
- 11 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept Rating 3.5: A different take on a paranormal romantic comedy with Richie and Priscilla both lost within the contemporary world—one clings to the past and refuses the future, one is a ghost who can’t leave the past. Clear target readership Rating 2: Could be better defined. A paranormal romantic comedy may suggest female readership, but the protagonist is geared more toward male readers. Hook Rating 3: The 1990s were an important time for modern technology coming into everyday use. Priscilla’s setting, a century earlier, is out-of-date like Richie is out of date to contemporary times. So the hook is: A slack…
Last reply by Phil Dandrea, -
MODULE 7: ASSIGNMENT 2: SCOREBOX: Criteria Ratings 1-5: MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept: 4 Well, I sure hope it is original. As for high-concept, that is something on which I have tried to focus. I know what my kids read, and I have many kids who have many friends. The story is fun, adventurous, romantic, dangerous, and a little bloody. I have done lots of editing to make sure it is not too wordy, and I have tried to delete some parts that might be boring. Clear target readership: 3 I am a little worried about this one. I wrote this for YA, and my teenagers do like it a lot, but that is not saying much. That is only…
Last reply by Laura Neibaur, -
- 0 replies
- 15 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept - 3-4 Bottom of the Breath is about a woman I understand (American, married, working) who is struggling with everyday life (aging, caregiving, insecurity, loss) who is presented with problems that may not be extraordinary (infidelity, family secrets, addiction) but are nevertheless important and compelling because it is happening to her, as it happens to all of us. Women find support in other women because we listen and we understand, and in the process of sharing, we do not feel so alone. I believe the women who read this book will see themselves and their lives in the story. There are many women writers wi…
Last reply by Jayne Mills, -
- 0 replies
- 26 views
Market Value Originality, Freshness, High Concept: 3.8 - Set in pre-Arthurian Britain (a time of the fairies, giants, and gods, when no humans yet inhabit the realm) this is an origin story of Excalibur, the Philosopher's Stone, and the warrior goddess Morgan le Fay. There are many Arthurian sagas, but this is a pre-Arthurian cycle, introducing Great Britain's most famous relics and icons, while leaving room for subsequent stories. I initially scored this category a four, yet the subject of fairies appears quite popular at the moment. Nonetheless, my novel interweaves actual British mythology and my own inventions in a manner that (I hope) exceeds its rivals. …
Last reply by WendyDRV, -
- 0 replies
- 8 views
Dear Writer, Below are coverage categories and criteria we use to help us rate novel projects. You need to use these criteria and do a self-audit of your novel, and you need to do it and post your coverage in this forum before approaching Author Salon with a call for a review of your novel-in-progress master profile you will create upon completion of the 16th module. Can you be honest with yourself? Even the most deluded narcissist will find it difficult to wade through the criteria below and "high five" themselves with supporting evidence. But then again, that's the whole idea. Pardon our sense of black humor! Please consider though ... How can you possibly appro…
Last reply by DanielJohnP, -
- 0 replies
- 10 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept – 4 – I think this works as high concept, is appealing, and relevant to everyone. High Concept – Yes, believe the following qualifies as that: High concept story concept: Woman evolves her identity in a parallel realm [*]High concept theme: Our current identity is only a fraction of what it could be. All humans can evolve their identity if they are open and willing to accept it. [*]High concept story premise: After being hunted by rival alien factions planning invasions of the Human Realm, a recently divorced psychic psychologist is swept into a parallel realm where she must evolve her identity in order …
Last reply by DonaldLilley, -
- 0 replies
- 10 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept - 5 - A solid 5 out of 5. Despite the at-first generic set up of a rogue military operation set against the backdrop of an alien invasion, the added plot line of the wife uncovering the government’s dark secret mixes things up by presenting a systemic problem that feeds into the greater existential threat. Clear target readership - 5 - Space opera / military science-fiction is a genre with a lot of cross-over appeal with different reading demographics, but at its core has a dedicated fandom hungry for fresh new content. Hook - 5 - The hook is boiled down to two lovers, a husband and wife, separated by ext…
Last reply by NicolasCalle, -
- 0 replies
- 25 views
The Self-Coverage Novel Scorebox Novel: The Zilos Chronicles: Rise of the Crimson Ravens, Science Fiction Fantasy Hybrid story. MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept: Score 4 There are some aspects of Rise of the Crimson Ravens that can be found in other stories. Even so, I believe my story has enough of a mix of fantasy, superhero and science fiction elements to stand out from what is out on the market. Rise of the Crimson Ravens takes place in the fictional world of Marvados, a world that utilizes elements from both fantasy and science fiction elements. I did this so that Rise of the Crimson Ravens could take in elements from both the past and …
Last reply by BenChewey, -
- 0 replies
- 27 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept, 4. The premise feels high concept. A medical student becomes acutely psychotic and falls in love with a woman he meets in the psychiatric hospital. The main characters are of Indian background, highly educated (one in medicine, the other in music), but troubled by mental illness. For Raj, bipolar disorder. For Smrita, borderline personality. Both of them are drawn to each other, for the wrong reasons, which has negative consequences. Clear target readership, 4. My target audience would be readers of women's, literary, and medical fiction. I'd also target Indian Americans or immigrants, as the main characters are 1s…
Last reply by Goa_Lit, -
- 0 replies
- 19 views
Self-Coverage Novel Scorebox Charles and Agnes, Historical Fiction, Susie Pruett MARKET VALUE Originality, freshness, high concept: 4 I believe these three categories are covered. The concept, an American heiress goes to London to marry a Viscount and falls in love with the Viscount’s valet is an idea that came from two of my favorite authors. I love P.G. Wodehouse’s character Jeeves and wondered what would happen if he ever fell in love. Another favorite author of mine is Edith Wharton. I combined her last book, “The Buccaneersâ€� about rich American girls going to Europe to marry titles with the idea of Jeeves and came up with the story of an Ameri…
Last reply by SusanPruett, -
- 0 replies
- 10 views
1. Uncertain 2. Understand, But Item Needs More Work 3. Average and Must Evolve To Be Competitive 4. I Believe This Base is Covered 5. Superb and Clicking With Velocity You must apply the above ratings to each of the criteria below, one at a time, and post the results here in your own personal topic. You must also support your ratings with references, discussion, and examples as appropriate. For example, you will simply not say, "Yeah, I'm good at dialogue, and I give myself a high five." No. You must reference the module that demonstrates the great dialogue. If you are reading this now while still working through your modules, you might want to consider this…
Last reply by AliQuigley, -
- 0 replies
- 14 views
Criteria Ratings 1-5 as follows: 1. Uncertain 2. Understand, But Item Needs More Work 3. Average and Must Evolve To Be Competitive 4. I Believe This Base is Covered 5. Superb and Clicking With Velocity MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept 2/3 I think there is value in looking at what it means to be a girl in Appalachia. But I think that has been done. What I think makes my story different is that she is also seen as "other" in that she has Cherokee ancestry. But the white people of White Lick Tennessee consider her trash. And the Cherokee nation will not consider her as part of their community due to not being on the Dawes Rolls. This…
Last reply by MelissaSeligman, -
- 0 replies
- 12 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept - 3 Think the voice has originality and freshness Has high concept – deals with several current themes – Module V – working 24/7 vs life; women vs women in workplace setting Per Maass, has a twist because she’s the workaholic –usually it’s the guy (Pretty Woman, Bringing up Baby but Two Weeks Notice, The Ugly Truth – she is workaholic) [*]Clear target readership – 4 (romantic comedy genre) [*] [*]Hook – 3 – I am not sure the hook is strong enough. When a workaholic lawyer meets a fun-loving music marketing executive, which partnership will she choose? It's Legal Bridget Jones meets W…
Last reply by KathyS, -
- 0 replies
- 33 views
Novel Scorebox Originality, freshness, high concept- Score 4: The aspect of the Tovenaar being bred and sold as conduits of electricity is not something I have come upon before and has garnered great attention. Clear target readership- Score 4: YA/Fantasy-Cath is sixteen and dealing with her first sexual encounters as well as growing in confidence from a child to a young adult. She is recognizing more about the world around her and exploring what is important to her personally. I toned down some of the aspects of sexual violence after several edits (decided they may be too much for YA although the idea of them is still present just not as graphic). Hook- Score…
Last reply by RMWilliams, -
- 0 replies
- 13 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept Score: 4.5 This is one of my strongest factors. Once I came up with the idea to write about Louis’ life and experiences, I searched and consulted with children’s librarians looking for middle grade novels that spoke extensively about colorism. There were not many historical fiction novels out there for that age group. I am confident that this topic is a conversation starter and the concept is unique enough to garner a reader’s interest. Clear target readership Score: 2.5 I continue to struggle with this. I’ve written a novel that I believed was geared towards the middle grade audience. However, s…
Last reply by GBryant, -
- 0 replies
- 13 views
MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept Score: 3.9 I realize writing about a princess and other royalty is nothing new, nor is having an evil queen as the antagonist. However, what helps the originality of my story is that it is not medieval in setting, nor do I focus on court intrigue and structure, and it is definitely NOT a fairytale. Instead, my royalty have superpowers that should no longer exist due to a mass genocide a century prior—known as the Impenocide—and my story explores what happens when the one wonder-drug everyone relies on to cure all disease and illness goes missing. Also, my two main characters do not play the typical roles of princes…
Last reply by KaraBosshardt, -
- 0 replies
- 15 views
Novel Scorebox/rough draft/M. Jantzi/THE BRAID Criteria: MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept: SCORE 4 Originality in the interweaving of particular forces of healing: art/learning to paint; horses/learning to ride; Indian history/present-day reservation life; friendship; and a strong inner desire of the protagonist, Catherine Moran, to reconcile with adulterous betrayal by husband, Jay Moran. Originality, also, in the interweaving of particular forces of hindrance: Catherine’s adult children’s resistance to her friendship/romance with David Blackfeather; David’s ex-wife, Marcy, who resents his involvement with other women; and Catherineâ…
Last reply by MaryEllen, -
- 0 replies
- 21 views
Criteria Ratings 1-5 as follows: 1. Uncertain 2. Understand, But Item Needs More Work 3. Average and Must Evolve To Be Competitive 4. I Believe This Base is Covered 5. Superb and Clicking With Velocity Note: Because I have two main characters, and most of their scenes are separate, some of my scores will be different, depending on the character. MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept (4) This is one of the few things I think I’ve really nailed - I’ve have had a hard time finding comparables, partly because there aren’t that many YA contemporary thrillers available, particularly told from two very different viewpoints. Clear tar…
Last reply by eldawson, -
- 0 replies
- 19 views
1. Uncertain 2. Understand, But Item Needs More Work 3. Average and Must Evolve To Be Competitive 4. I Believe This Base is Covered 5. Superb and Clicking With Velocity MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept 4—I’ve never read a book with a grandmother and granddaughter on a road trip together and I think this is an often overlooked relationship in the literary world [*]Clear target readership 4—book club fiction, women’s fiction (giving it a 4 because I think both of these categories are kind of nebulous—also because there are some New Adult fiction aspect or even YA) [*]Hook 3—haven’t had a ton of positive response to my p…
Last reply by MaryHelenSheriff, -
- 0 replies
- 17 views
Self-Coverage Novel Scorebox Redux Market Value: · Originality, freshness, high concept: Score 5 (I haven’t read any books, to date, that delve exclusively in Hawaiian gods, history and culture while weaving in fantasy. I’ve read books that touch upon it, but never fully immersed.) · Clear target readership: Score 4 · Hook: Score 5 (I rewrote my hook a few times. I wanted to focus on the Hawaiian gods first and foremost, so the reader is immediately grabbed while touching on haole, skin color and racism.) Structure: · Act Zero backstory development: Score 4 (I’ve done a lot of backstory development and tried to interweave it within my story witho…
Last reply by Brooke Hutchins, -
- 0 replies
- 19 views
1. Uncertain 2. Understand, But Item Needs More Work 3. Average and Must Evolve To Be Competitive 4. I Believe This Base is Covered 5. Superb and Clicking With Velocity MARKET VALUE: Originality, freshness, high concept: (High concept = can it be easily transitioned into a film, or is it worthy of being made into a film): Score 4 Clear target readership: Score 2 Hook: Score 4 STRUCTURE: Act Zero backstory development: (I feel this was an easy one as there is so much Arthurian lore to lean on, but even so, I generated a great deal of backstory that is not in this book, but I established it anyway just in case): Score 5 Concise, effective setu…
Last reply by SaulHansen, -
- 0 replies
- 13 views
Content Removed.
Last reply by DVMulligan, -
- 0 replies
- 14 views
Market Value · Originality, freshness, high-concept – 4.5 There are a number of aspects of Catalyst that I believe is original. First of all, the idea that telepathic ability is a catastrophic handicap equivalent to blindness or paralysis is a different look at an ability normally perceived as a superhuman trait. Secondly, although the concept of hyperspace is often used to solve the distance problem of science fiction, Catalyst uses the concept as an active ingredient of the story, enabling the protagonist, Shaanti, to cope with her disability. Also hyperspace has characteristics developed that causes it to play a role as an obstacle that the characters have to …
Last reply by DvanderVeen,